Trump’s the loser as GOP falters

November 9, 2022

Source: Axios

Former President Trump is facing waves of blame after key Republican candidates lost in midterms.

The big picture: There was no red wave. As of this morning, control of the Senate is undetermined, but appears to be leaning toward Democrats. The House is headed for a very narrow GOP majority, but is also uncalled.

Why it matters: Regardless of the reality with GOP primary voters, Republican elites — and other anti-Trump Republicans — sense blood in the water. There’s an increased likelihood of a larger, more boisterous primary field competing against Trump in 2024.

The chances Trump can clear the field are vastly diminished.

What happened: Many of former President Trump’s handpicked candidates were defeated or struggled in otherwise winnable races — a lineup of underachievers.

In Pennsylvania, Mehmet Oz lost his Senate race to Democrat John Fetterman by 2+ points. In Michigan, Tudor Dixon lost her challenge to Gov. Gretchen Whitmer (D) by 8 points.
Trump-backed candidates who are trailing: Herschel Walker for the Senate, in Georgia … and Blake Masters for the Senate, in Arizona.
On top of all that, Trump stoked a massive distraction by promoting speculation about his own 2024 campaign in the midterms’ final hours.

The intrigue: Trump’s planned rally at Mar-a-Lago next Tuesday, where he’s expected to announce a 2024 presidential campaign, now won’t come after a GOP landslide.

Instead, it will follow an election where Democrats have a solid chance to hold or even expand their hold on the Senate — and where Republicans fell way short of their expectations for a sizable red wave.

What he said: Trump said in a TruthSocial post on Wednesday that the election “was somewhat disappointing,” but “from my personal standpoint it was a very big victory.”

Between the lines: Trump constrained his party’s coalition in states where he showed up. In Pennsylvania, Senate victor John Fetterman won independents with 57% of the vote, Hispanics with 67% of the vote and women with 57% of the vote, according to exit polling.

In Georgia, where the Senate race is too close to call, Trump-championed Herschel Walker won only 8% of the Black vote, 42% of independents and 39% of Hispanics, exit polls show. His numbers in all three categories lagged Gov. Brian Kemp (R), who won re-election.

By contrast, Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis’ resounding re-election was one of the few bright spots for Republicans.

DeSantis’ 20-point victory — carrying some big, largely Hispanic counties, including Miami-Dade and Osceola — will provide rocket fuel for a possible presidential campaign.

What to watch: DeSantis wants to run badly and will argue he has similar beliefs to Trump — but can deliver much bigger, broader wins.

The bottom line: Trump’s promotion of candidates outside the political mainstream — or celebrities without political experience — proved to be costly for Republicans. DeSantis’ Florida model offers Republicans an alternative path. But Trump won’t let the party move on without a fight.

House Republican Leader Kevin McCarthy had been expected to take the stage of his election-night party at a D.C. hotel as early as 10 p.m.

But come midnight, the main venue floor was empty as a small group of aides and staffers mingled near the open bar.

At 1:59 a.m., McCarthy finally declared from the stage: “It is clear we are going to take the House back.”

Minutes before, his staff gathered the remaining supporters and directed them to “Grab a sign” and “Pack it in” to the area in front of the stage, where cameras would be showing his speech live.

Editor’s note: This version updates results.

Relevant and recent posts

Mike Pence on Leadership and the Future of the Republican Party

Former US Vice President Mike Pence looks back on the events of January 6 2021, his final days in office with President Trump and his…

Thought Leader: Mike Pence

Marc Short on U.S. Investment in Critical Minerals

Why do critical minerals matter now? Marc Short explains how U.S. investment in critical minerals fits into a broader strategy around economic security, manufacturing, and…

Thought Leader: Marc Short